On Wednesday, on the margins of the APEC summit in Shenzhen, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin held a bilateral meeting, and the Chinese leader told his guest that the two countries should take more concrete steps toward what he calls a multipolar world. Putin, for his part, said their partnership was performing well on the international stage. It was the first of the encounters that will matter this week. On Thursday the same two men are due to sit down with Donald Trump, in a three-way meeting the White House has confirmed and that has no real precedent.
On paper this is the 33rd APEC Leaders’ Meeting, a club of 21 economies that together produce roughly 60 percent of global output, meeting under the slogan “Building an Asia-Pacific Community to Prosper Together.” In practice the formal sessions have become the scenery. China is running a curated, abridged format that leaves little room for informal diplomacy, and one report described Beijing as showing it can shape multilateralism on its own terms. A crowded multilateral setting also squeezes everything else. Analyst Yun Sun told Brookings that any Trump-Xi encounter here will be far shorter than their meetings in Beijing and Washington this year.
The digital agenda shows why the corridors are busier than the hall. Beijing wants artificial intelligence cooperation at the centre of the week. Last year in Gyeongju Xi proposed a World Artificial Intelligence Cooperation Organization, possibly based in Shanghai, and Washington answered that it rejects governing AI through international bodies. This time Brookings experts expect, at best, an endorsement of a bilateral AI dialogue and an incident-reporting channel, while chip export controls and a recent Nvidia scandal hang over the room, according to Al Jazeera. The word “digital” means a shared rulebook in one capital and a competitive lead in the other. When the main table cannot reconcile that, the work moves to side rooms.
Putin’s own remarks in Shenzhen carried a similar double meaning. Addressing business leaders, he said the tools of economic coercion belong to the past, then acknowledged that tariffs, export limits and sanctions still halt development. He spoke as a leader under sanctions, in the home of his largest partner, at a forum meant to celebrate open trade. Euronews reports that his talks with Xi were expected to range over energy, finance and foreign policy, including Ukraine and North Korea. Xi, meanwhile, described the relationship as a model of equality, and he carries his own worry into the week: the war with Iran and the closure of the Strait of Hormuz have disrupted China’s oil supply.
It is tempting to describe this as the West watching from outside, but the picture is odder than that. The American president is in the building. Trump skipped last year’s APEC summit after meeting Xi, and this time he arrives for a trilateral that the White House says will focus on nuclear proliferation, with the New START treaty having lapsed in February. A senior US official has said no agreement is expected, and an administration official told reporters Trump will not raise Ukraine. Pyotr Tolstoy, a Russian lawmaker, has called the format a possible “new Yalta,” while Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov insisted its outcomes cannot be imposed on other nations.
The people actually left outside are those without a seat. Europeans are not APEC members, and the analyst Constanze Stelzenmüller has put the European complaint plainly: no decisions about Europe without Europe. Ukraine is absent from the agenda altogether. Japan’s prime minister, Sanae Takaichi, is making her first China trip in office amid the Taiwan row, and Japanese officials have been working to guard against a snub from Xi, with contact likely limited to occasions such as the leaders’ dinner.
What does this kind of parallel diplomacy produce? Analysts quoted by Brookings disagree on the answer. Ryan Hass sees Russia gaining legitimacy and Trump facing more downside than upside. Scott Moore warns the image of three great powers talking could signal a concert of strongman states and push allies to hedge. Jonathan Czin calls it pantomime diplomacy, and Simon Mabon expects photo opportunities rather than peace. They may be right that nothing will be signed. But signing was never the only purpose. The photograph is itself a product, and the sequence matters: Russian negotiators have just spent weeks in Abu Dhabi pressing for security deals with individual NATO states, and Shenzhen offers the same logic on a bigger stage.
The consequences will fall unevenly. Europe faces the fear, voiced in the Brookings preview, that a US-China bargain could push Chinese overcapacity onto European markets or write trade rules without it. And institutions like APEC risk turning into venues for hire, where the programme is public and the decisions are made upstairs.
The formal declaration will arrive on Thursday evening, as declarations always do. The next real test comes later, with the G20 in Florida in December and the expiry of the US-China trade truce in January. By then it will be clear whether Shenzhen produced a new habit or only a good picture.
